Skip navigation

3D Printing

2 Posts authored by: kitfud

This story extends from my last blog post (click, HERE, to view)....

 

It wasn't long before the simple models printed on my new Printerbot "Simple" did not meet my expectations. View the pictures below:

IMG_0083.JPGIMG_0089.JPG

First off, the picture on the left represents a series of prints cancelled mid way through the process. What you'll notice is that the texture of, what should be a gem of a 3mm cube is all smashed together. This is the result of the Z probe (the up and down movement) not being calibrated properly. When things are working out okay, then the square on the right occurs, and you'll notice too that the texture of the square cannot really be defined as "smooth." These mediocre prints resulted in an endless series of printer bed calibrations. All to make sure the printing surface was perfectly flat and also adjusting the G-code in the Cura software so the nozzle drifts higher or lower as it drops plastic out. In the end, the perfect specimen was never achieved during the early stages of my life with the Printerbot.

 

One day I was sickened by the dastardly prints being produced which looked like nuggets of plastic junk. Our school "Technology Integrator" came into my room and I told him exactly what the problem was; to reiterate what the problem was it's that the 3D printer was not printing out decent 3D objects. Thus, I offered my desk up as an opportunity for him to work with the device until I returned from teaching a class. And when I did return it was to my horror that this had occurred:

 

 

To this day I don't know how the printer nozzle hovering above the bed occurred as things were never this bad before I left to my class. But if the video does not state the obvious, you'll notice that the Printerbot is printing way up above the printer bed and that can't be right. This put me into a panic because how was I supposed to produce six Pokemon models for my 6th grade advisory group. Models which had failed to print only days before as a result of becoming unglued from the printer bed (I'll get back to this in a bit).......I had promised people all sorts of trinkets....dolphins, Notre Dame figurines, monkeys, elephants and pen holders....oh the feeling of destiny delayed.

 

Having the Printerbot not return to printing anywhere close to the surface put me into a lonely state of mind. When I'd return to work each morning and see the piece of junk sitting on my desk I'd feel like I lost my pet cat Felix to an automobile. Felix was my favorite cat and even today, I miss him terribly.

 

And every single time I'd press the print model button in Cura the nozzle of the machine would move out to a location on the bed, raise up a little bit, stop for a while, then continue raising up to the ridiculously high point while dripping plastic.

 

I tried everything to fix the Printerbot. I even flashed the micro-controller board at the bottom of the machine per the instructions listed on the Printerbot page. Nonetheless, my valuable prize was quickly turning into a piece of metal non-sense. Poets would probably have a field day painting a picture of how useless the thing was in words....

 

Even as I went through every online forum I could, every Google search I could bring myself to produce, nothing changed. In the depths of my desperation, hitting rock bottom,  I loaned the printer out to our school's IT technician. Anything to fix the machine at this point and he decided to take it home for the weekend this was the result:

 

Yes, the micro controller board is smoking! Producing the types of fumes that make you feel like your fertility is dropping with each puff. This was definitely not the kind of smoke you'd find in a Jimmy Buffet concert. Nonetheless, this was an absolute disaster for me and I was distraught. My lovely printer was failing miserably. It was at this point that I felt I had reason to request some type of product exchange so I first contact element14.com who then referred me to the Printerbot to deal with repairs. The picture below shows the point at which the damage on the board had occurred:

IMG_0100.JPGIMG_0101.JPG

 

The video of the microcontroller board smoking was actually made for "Mike" who works at Printerbot. Mike must have woken up each morning with another of my requests to fix the thing. He probably thought I was composed of printerbot "noobness," over his Starbucks coffee- that was until I sent this video of the printer smoking. I just wanted my gem of a prize to work again, to feel the warm glow of elation each time a new Pokemon figurine was produced rather than the buzzing of the printer dropping more loads than a flock of sea gulls.

 

To the Printerbot people's credit they eventually sent me a new microcontroller board (upgraded to a higher revision) and also a new Z probe sensor:

printerbot z probe.jpg

I forgot to mention that the expedited shipment of the Z probe happened after a couple weeks because they were out of stock of the microcrontroller boards. Which made me ponder...were the issues I was having something others were experiencing as well? Maybe my suffering is shared; like a Jungian sort of thing?

 

Anyway, turns out that the board and sensor really was the issue because now my Printerbot was actually printing on the surface bed. There were two other issues though, the first was terrifying again, in that when the Z probe would lower to the printing bed there would be a loud crashing thump. Sounded like something crashing, and it turns out that this was the result of this screw being loose in the mechanism which raises and lowers the printing nozzle:

IMG_0114.JPG

There are still times when I have to tighten up this screw which I think comes loose from having to manually re-calibrate the Z probe from time to time; this process of re-calibration involves screwing the Z probe shaft down again after raising it up 30 mm and this probably has some type of undesirable effect on the screws. Another "screw" problem which I experienced was the spool feeder not feeding the plastic filament into the extruder. Observe the following video to see what I mean:

 

The red mark I made on the filament with a pen is not moving so obviously plastic is not being fed through the small cog leading into the extruder. Turns out that you have to turn the screw located at the top of the cog so the filament gets locked (or rather pinched) into place and the "bite" marks on the feeder actually grip the plastic to put it in motion.

 

All these issues aside and once fixed, the most frustrating difficulty I had involved the things I was printing not sticking to the surface. Notice the following cancellations to prints I had to make as a result of the issue:

IMG_0092.JPGIMG_0094.JPGIMG_0096.JPGIMG_0097.JPG

What an absolute waste of plastic!

 

I can't describe how frustrating it is to have your model print for a couple hours and then have to cancel it as a result of the bits slipping off of the surface. Half those Pokemons look like they were guillotined by Louis XVI; Pokemons probably have no necks thus why they are severed at the trunk?...In the end, we tried to use hair spray over the blue tape (as this was what was recommended online) and this worked somewhat better. Also, I adjusted the temperature at which the PLA plastic was extruded through the nozzle; but nothing worked all that well. So, my solution was to line the board with double sided duck tape to absolutely guarantee that my models would not shift during the print:

You can see that with models with a narrow small base which would otherwise have issues now stick.  However, double sided tape is not ideal because:

 

1. It is expensive

2. Sometimes it's hard to remove from the printing bed.

 

Additionally: NEVER use double sided carpet tape. I found this out the hard way.....that stuff does not come off of a metal surface easily....

 

These days, I've figured out that you need to experiment with the brand of blue printers tape that you use. I've found one from Lowes that I like and in combination with hair spray being layered on the surface just before the print, so it hardens and becomes sticky as the first layers appear, you can finally achieve a satisfactory print. There are times though, when I want to guarantee that my model will not be messed up so I use the double sided duck tape and this also involves the additional hassle of having to re-calibrate the Z probe slightly higher to account for the tape's thickness. The prints that I make now also involve me selecting an option in Cura which is to lay down a "brim" around the model. What this is is a series of lines (think of it as a skirt) to your model which widens the base further and provides added adhesion between the structure and the bed. The drawback in having to do this is two fold:

 

1. Your print will take longer to produce and

2. You will use up more of your PLA plastic in the process of laying down a brim around your model

 

So there you have it! A plethora of problems which those with the Printerbot Metal Simple will hopefully never have to experience. Once all these issues were worked out I managed to achieve a series of wonderful prints which kick started my ideas for how to use the 3D printer as a tool for the classroom. My next blog post will explore the form factor of those prints and also how the settings within Cura have to be experimented with and manipulated depending upon the characteristics of the model you try to produce.

My third blog in the series "Reaping the Rewards" focuses on the cheerful topic of successfully printing 3D objects. You'll notice that this post is considerably more "rosy" than the trials and tribulations and the quirkiness of my first impressions with the Printerbot Simple Metal.

 

Once you get your machine working (and trust me, I know how annoying this can be) the Printerbot website recommends that you print the "fan shroud." At first I didn't really know what this thing was, or what is could be used for, but I quickly learned that this shroud was an enhancement that you could print for your machine. Like if Optimus Prime made himself a hat at a crafts fair. Even though the Printerbot fan worked fine, it made sense to do another test print of something which would ultimately improve the quality of this roller coaster of a machine:

 

IMG_0107.JPGIMG_0109.JPG

After all the repairs and failed prints I'd experienced with the Printerbot I was very pleased with the result of the "fan shroud." The edges were precise and the layering of the plastic was barely noticeable when you ran your fingers up and down the model. I'd say that the shroud was perfect aside from how the holes used for mounting it to the Printerbot Simple Metal were too small and had to be drilled bigger to fit screws. How annoying; but I'm guessing that is the result of the CAD .stl file rather than the quality of the printer itself. dratt........

 

My first impressions of the shroud are that it doesn't do anything noticeable. Like Falcao for Manchester United:

images.jpg

 

Once installed you'll notice how the shroud is aimed at the extruder nozzle which should filter cooled air towards the tip, thus cooling the PLA plastic at a faster rate. What becomes a problem though is when you "home" the extruder; bring it back to the starting position for the print. Sometimes the wires behind the printer get jammed against the base of the shroud and printer. It's hard to describe this in words, but it pinches the wires against the metal structure and this creates a dreadful sound.

 

Printing enhancements didn't stop with just the shroud, as I decided to get creative and craft some spool feeders for the top of the Printerbot. This provided me with purpose as I learned the CAD program, Sketchup. This is what the spool feeders look like; almost like mini beer mugs turned upside down:

IMG_0115.JPG

The feeders I designed worked out very well until recently:

IMG_0096.JPG

As the photo above shows the extruder probe finishing off a large model at almost the maximum height it can print. Notice the filament jammed up "rainbow style" in my feeder cups which caused the filament to jump outside of the cog used to draw the plastic into the extruder (this is shown by the arrow). This was a joy kill as it happened after attempting to print something for 13 hours over night. When I returned to my office the next morning this is what I saw:

IMG_0095.JPG

Nothing was coming out of the extruder nozzle for the last couple hours of the print and as you can see, the cougar has the top of it's head missing. There are times when I can relate.

 

On a different note from this mega fail, the above picture is helpful for the next topic which is how to support overhangs on your model ("zero space") and also create a balance between printing speed and surface quality.

 

If the Printerbot is calibrated correctly it will be able to print over zero space (overhangs of up to 90 degrees successfully). Just like the 3mm square was used to figure out if your Printerbot is working there is a printable model to check your machines ability to print in zero space- this is known as the "Bridge Torture Test":

bridge-torture-test_50mm_preview_featured.jpg

The bridge torture test takes about 15 minutes and you'll want to experiment with the settings in CURA for the speed of the nozzle and temperature which the PLA filament get's extruded. Here is an example I made with my printer:

IMG_0087.JPG

This is a half decent print and what I've found is that for the "Bridge Torture Test" to be successful you need to figure out the fastest setting your printer can run at and a setting closest to the lowest temperature your PLA fillament can melt at. Different PLA you'll find, have distinct optimal temperatures so don't assume the settings you find for one brand are fit for all.

 

Fast speed and low temp PLA settings solidify very quickly and is laid down stiff just like planks on a bridge would. However, these settings would not translate well into all types of prints too. When you are printing a figurine or spherical object, for example, you'll notice a drop in quality when the printer is running at too fast. It is therefore a dance between achieving the ability to print in zero space and also produce a silky smooth surface for your model. Here are some examples of the "Bridge Torture Test" failing. The photo on the left is a result of the speed of the printer being way too fast with filament being too hot; the photo on the right is when the filament exudes too cool relative to the speed of the nozzle.

IMG_0088.JPGIMG_0094.JPG

 

Silky smooth may be the better compromise because in CURA you have the option of selecting automatic supports to be printed with your model. These are shown by arrows in the cougar picture below:

IMG_0095.JPG

The supports do exactly what you'd expect them too: hold up overhangs on your model so they can be printed without dripping down like a Dali painting . These supports can then be snapped off of your model but will leave a slight indentation. What I have done to improve my models as a result of these indentations is use a dremel tool (a battery powered sander) to smooth out the model. For me, supports are the way to go and I am still experimenting with the best settings for employing them in the Cura software. For example, you have the option of telling the computer when to lay these down depending upon a specified overhang on your model like, putting down some supports when the overhang is 40 degrees rather than 90.

 

When everything comes together you can see from the following pictures that the quality of the Printerbot Simple Metal's prints are great:

IMG_0086.JPG

That is an anchor and the Pokemon, Bulbasaur! I got both of the .stl models for these prints from the website www.yeggi.com . Yeggi is the Google of 3D printing files. You type in what you are looking for and the search engine scours the internet for a file. I've done this whenever someone has asked me for a trinket. Such as the following:

P1040918.JPGP1040919.JPGP1040922.JPGP1040923.JPGP1040924.JPG

All charming prints...

 

There were a few times I attempted to print something more ambitious, something that would take many hours to produce and in the end, would be something I'd leave overnight for the printer to produce. Over the memorial day weekend I took the 3D printer back to my house and the rumbling of the machine was constant.

 

Observe example 1 Attilio Piccirilli 's "Fragelina":

 

 

And now the Printerbot Simple "Fragelina":

P1040925.JPG

Nice....except for how the models are headless! The smaller model on the left came unstuck from the printing bed and the larger one on the right had the filament pop out of the exuder cog as it did with the incomplete cougar model at the beginning of this blog post. These were frustrating instances because I'd leave these things printing overnight and then return to seeing them mutilated by the Printerbot.


Observe example 2: Michelangelo's "Pieta"

pieta.jpg


Arguably one of the most famous statues of all time, one which made Michelangelo famous, rich and desired....let's see the Printerbot version can do the same for me because one day I do want to shop at Whole Foods:

 

P1040926.JPG

Not bad! And I was extremely impressed until I noticed a huge error that the Printerbot made which was to mis-print Jesus' legs!:

P1040928.JPG

Because I left the machine running overnight I don't really know what happened to produce this. Flaws asside, the detail achieved by the Printerbot is quite astounding.

 

Besides printing other people's stuff I've also been designing my own works. When I found out I was getting a 3D printer I went to a local Barnes and Noble and bought "Sketchup for Dummies"

which in conjunction with youtube.com tutorials taught me how to create shapes like a sphere, code, push/pull squares, boxes and group objects. This enabled me to design functional, replacement parts for my Zumo robot chassis:

 

IMG_1503.JPGFullSizeRender.jpg

And craft an interesting mini sculptures to rival Michelangelo- "This Is What Winning Looks Like":

 

P1040921.JPG

I think it's quite beautiful and would go very well on Warren Buffet's toilet.

 

In the end, learning how to use "Sketchup" has been one of the most fantastic experiences- one which I have come to enjoy sharing with students in and out of the classroom. My next blog will focus on how I have used the Printerbot Simple Metal in classes with students and also, for crafting "school materials.". Check back for more details in the near future

Filter Blog

By date: By tag: